Ranthambhore – Sariska and tiger shuttle – Part II
……….About a year ago the Rajasthan Forest Department declared that they would relocate tigers from Ranthambhore to Sariska to right the wrong. When they fist came out with this plan almost everyone (including me) laughed at it. Most people (not me this time) had declared Sariska as history. A few months after it came out in the news that there were no tigers in Sariska – four of us – Dr. Dharmendra Khandal (Field Biologist of Tiger Watch), Dr. Amit Kotia (a fine botanist), Juhi Chaudhry (the then co-coordinator Kids for Tigers) and I – had gone to Sariska for a few days. At that time the Project Tiger and the Government of Rajasthan were still denying that tiger had been wiped out from Sariska. We had some great wildlife moments there. The habitat was amazing but the tigers were missing. Just a few weeks after we came back they government finally conceded that there were no tiger left in Sariska.
This was a big blow to the Rajasthan Forest Department and the Project Tiger, in fact, to the entire conservation movement in India. But nothing much changed. The budgets, priorities, procedures and staff stayed the same. But a handful of officers of the Rajasthan Forest Department and the Rajasthan police worked their heart out. The protection level went up dramatically. A number of poachers were apprehended and suddenly the poaching community (mainly members of the Mogiya and Bawaria hunting gathering tribes) was on the run. A convicted tiger poacher from Ranthambhore – Devi Singh Mogiya – told us this, on camera. The Mogiyas and Bawarias are off shoots of the larger Pardhi tribe. The general public opinion is that these people are extremely dangerous, very secretive and totally ruthless. They maybe ruthless for wildlife but they are really scared of any kind authority. They may be secretive but at the local level I was common knowledge that they were poaching big time. It is just that no one really bothered about them, till Sariska happened.
Once the protection level increased tiger numbers in Ranthambore gradually recovered. In May 2005 the Rajasthan State Empowered Committee had declared that there were 26 tigers in Ranthambhore, which was untrue. At that time there were only 18 tigers – 13 adults and 5 cubs. Till a month or so ago there were 23 adults (one of the earlier 18 – Yuvraj - a young male was killed by Mogiyas somewhere in the end of November and six newer cubs had grown up), 6 sub adults and 8 young cubs. I could be wrong here by one or two but that would be about it.
Left and Right cheek markings of the first male tiger (T 10 or the Darra male)that was moved from Ranthambhore to Sariska
There were recent media reports that the forest authorities had sighted 14 cubs (below the age of 4 months) during the hot summer months of 2008. This was hogwash. There are right now 8 cubs (in four different families) and not 14. And out of these 8 only 4 had been positively till the end of May. I don’t know how this figure of 14 came up. Anyways these figures are not really important. What is more relevant is that the population is on the recovery mode. Ranthambhore is not overflowing with tigers (as it is made out to be) but it is definitely on a rapid recovery mode.
By the beginning of this year the relocation plan became very serious. A lot of our “cocktail party” conservationists were dead against the plan. A few (that included me) were skeptical about it (in fact till a month ago I use to think that the Forest Department may not finally have the nerve to pull it off) but were not against it in principle. This was the only idea if Sariska had to be revived as a tiger reserve. The habitat and prey was there in Sariska but the tiger was missing. The experiment had to be tried out, even if it failed.
I have not been to Sariska in the last 6 months but the news that I was getting was that a few, actually five, enclosures – where the tigers would be released as soon as they reach Sariska. Once the tigers get over their “trauma” of the journey, they would be released.
By the second week of May most parts of the park were closed for tourists. The only part that was left open was the area of the lakes and the part from the lakes to a forest guard post called Guda (towards the southern end of the Ranthambore national park). The tourists were not complaining because this is one of the most popular part of the national park. Monitoring of tigers in the closed part of the park was intensified and some tigers were short listed for relocation. By the middle of June a few of the shortlisted tigers were radio collared, besides the three that had been radio collared some months ago.
Left and right flank markings of the second tiger that was moved to Sariska - a female called Bachhi
The tigers that were shortlisted were young tigers that had separated from their mothers about a year or so ago. A tiger of that age group would have just about established (particularly females) their territories in Ranthambhore but would not have been totally entrenched there. To move even one tiger, four or five would have to be identified so that they would be able to surely find one of them to tranquilize a few hours before they were to be air lifted.
The plan was to make a stopgap helipad inside the Ranthambore national park, where an Indian air force helicopter could land. Experts from the Wildlife Institute of India would tranquilize one of the identified tigers, put them in a covered cage, load this cage on the helicopter and fly them to Sariska, where they would be released inside the enclosures. Sounds easy but it is very difficult to pull off.
In late 2007, three tigers were radio collared in Ranthambore for monitoring purpose. When this was done, we suddenly realized that the Forest Department was serious about shifting tigers to Sariska. One of these three tigers – a male that is slightly over 3 years old and is known as the Darra male or T 10 – was the first tiger that was the first tiger to be relocated to Sariska. The helicopter arrived in Ranthambhore on the evening of the 28th of June. The idea was to relocate the first (of the five – 2 males and 3 females) tiger on the morning of the 29th. It almost did not work out because it was raining heavily on the 29th morning. The tiger (Darra male) was located and the entire forest team was waiting for the rains to stop. Slightly after 1000 hours or so the rain stopped, the tiger was tranquilized, put in the cage and airlifted. It was real touch and go. The tiger recovered from the tranquilizing dose in midair but was still too dazed to move around. They managed to land him in Sariska and move the cage to one of the enclosures. The top brass of Rajasthan Forest Department was in the helicopter with the tiger.
A forest officer told me that the moment they opened the gate of the cage, the tiger almost charged out of it and hid behind some bushes in the enclosure. They had left a bait for him in the enclosure, which he killed a few hours after being released but did not eat till much later.
On the 6th of July a tigress, known here as Bachhi (or daughter – because she is the daughter of a Ranthambhore most famous tigress – Machali – from the last litter) was similarly moved. This time the entire operation went like clockwork. Bachhi was my favorite, an absolute beauty, and I have some amazing pictures of her. What was interesting is that these two were territorial neighbors and had mated about a month ago. Both of them are still very young so the mating may not be fruitful but they would be surely recognizing each other’s scent. A day after Bachhi reached Sariska, the Darra male was released from his enclosure. He is now free to establish his domain. The forest department has been cleared the first big hurdle but there is still a big hill to climb. I am sure they will climb it.
In the map pasted below Bachhi's territory is marked in red, while the Darra male’s territory is marked out in black. Hope they do well.
Hats off to officers like R N Mehrotra (Chief Wildlife Warden, Rajasthan), R S Shekhawat (Deputy Field Director, Ranthambhore national park), R S Somashekhar (DFO Sariska) and their supporting staff. You pulled out the first two rabbits out of the hat. Congrats.
Labels: Bengal tiger, ranthambhore, ranthambore, sariska, tiger conservation, tiger relocation, wildlife conservation


13 Comments:
Hi Aditya
Thanks for bringing this important updates on this project ... It's true that suddenly many people are taking interest in Tigers and Tiger conservation :) and like myself many are thinking that they can have some opinion about the Sariska project ... I know I don't have field experience with tigers but some thoughts and concerns always come to my mind out of common sense -
1. Sariska officials could not manage it in the past so what is the hope that it is possible now unless new people are brought into the force.
2. There are so many villages inside the park who were happy to help the poachers thinking that without tigers around their livestocks will be safer and they will get some money out of it. So without relocating these people how the dept is hoping to make this project a success ??
I feel these concerns comes to mind very easily ... I hope the Dept. also has this common sense and thinking to take care of it otherwise Sariska will become a Tiger-Farm for the Poachers ... the Dept will sow and they will harvest !!
I will Thank you again for this Blog ... Best Wishes to You and Poonam
Regards
Das
Superb Post. Thanks for sharing such a detailed one. It answered so many questions I had in my mind. It was also good to learn that bachhi and the darra male had adjoining territories and also did have a mating fling earlier. Hope they do well in Sariska..and the whole project turns out successful.
Look forward to meeting you sometime soon.
Hi Aditya,
It must be a great feeling to be closely associated with a 'world's first'-relocating tigers in the wild. Great Blog!
Hope NG/Discovery are documenting the effort on film.
Susan
Hi, I think I need to post another one instead of writing long comments :). Should be up by tomorrow.
Very informative and detailed post. It is nice that you share your intimate knowledge of the park and issues associated with it.
I am sure the relocation plan will be great success.
Somesh Goyal
read your posts after a long time. except that you are rather generous (and i dint expect you to be too critical of our friendly forest officials), you are doing excellent! much better than so many boring media tales... why don't you add a post on the other collared tigers at ranthambhore...i think five of them, or more?
ps: thanx for the pic! and since you indeed mention me as a friend (and kindly mention me quite a few times!), you HAVE TO spell my surname right...
..That's like the dyed in the wool RanAditya that we know off :--)))
You are back in true( green) colours of yours.
Are the poachers still hanging by the park fringes?
How did the villagers respond to this development ?
I am sorry for such a unsolicited suggestion but kindly pay a visit to Sariska.
Since then you will be able to give us a ringside view.
I cant go there and even if I do
tigers are not "BEDFELLOWS" with me ;-)).
You know them a lot better than me.
Back to my previous queries:
* Did the cashpooling for the Ranthombhore dam fructify ?
* Have the tigers colonised the Indala Plateau ?
..finally
Do you still have doubts about my --SERIOUSNESS
of your blog ;-))
Grab a gatorade and put our well meaning queries to rest.
Hope you keep giving life to this park.
God Bless a Ton
Dear Anubhav,
Back in true colours :) is a good one. The answer to your queries are:
1. Are the poachers still hanging by the park fringes? - Yes they are. The Mogiyas (traditionally the people who are most actively involved in poaching) live here. They are here for good. However, the Mogiyas who have settled around the park are not the really dangerous ones. That is because these guys are "tagged" and the local authorities keep a watch on them. The real bad ones are the migrants who come from some other district, do their "work" and get out. They get support and information from the Mogiyas who are settled here. Maybe the guys who are settled here are the real "bad guys" for some other park.
2. How did the villagers respond to this development ? - Tiger do not make any difference to the villagers around Ranthambhore. That is the sad part of tiger conservation in India. We have tigers here because the villagers decided not to kill them off but they do not benefit from it. A few do but only a handful. Wildlife conservation will not make much of a break through in India till it makes economic sense. (Hopefully my next post). Some villagers in Sariska protested about relocation of tigers because they feel that the higway will be moved from there and they will loose their source of living.
3. The cash pool for the waterholes in Indala and the dam - It rocked. believe me it did. The three wells and their associated waterholes are just amazing. They attract a lot of wildlife, including tigers. Right now tigers are using these waterholes very very frequently. But whether they have established their permanent territories - we can only tell after monitoring the area for a year or so. I am sure they will. The only problem with Indala was lack of permanent waterholes. We had pooled the cash from very very close friends and plan to stick to this philosophy very strictly in the future. There is group of people here who are spreading the word that we made a lot of money in the waterhole project. We actually ended up spending an amount which my wife had saved up for a month long vacation to Europe. In future we will ensure that we give them no ammo for spreading their gossip. There is a small group of people in India who are the "contractors" for saving India's tigers. Most of them run rich NGOs and do not like anyone else to do any conservation work and they don't do a thing.
4. Going to Sariska - Right now is not a good time. That place is a media circus right now and I am not part of the media. Let the hype die down and it will very soon. Once that happens the time would be right to go for a long trip to Sariska. That is when you would get the real story and not right now.
Cheers,
Aditya Singh
Dear Jay,
Got the point. I will fix the spelling of your surname. I have never used your surname as such and even in my phone book youur name is stored as Jay (I dont know any other Jay) :)
I was not too critical of the forest officials because to give them their due they are finally doing something, which is a huge break from the past. That was the only reason. I have had my share of war with the Forest Department (and I am sure that I will keep having it in the future) but I feel I have to give them their due when they do something positive. Till just a few weeks ago there was hardly anyone who thought that they would pull the tiger relocation off. At least our tiger experts did not. But the Forest Department pulled it off pretty easily. You just have to give them their due when they deserve it. Constant criticism of the Forest Department is a Wildlife NGO line and I am not an NGO wallah. :)
Cheers,
Aditya Singh
The fact remains that Mogiyas are involved in poaching. The one in Ranthambhore aid and abet wildlife crimes. Monitoring is not of the required level and rehabilitation of Mogiyas is only partial in the sense that no sustainable alternate means of livelihood has been provided. I would suggest another cashpool for the education of Mogiyas in the best school in Ranthambhore or Swai Madhopur so that these people can be weaned away from crime. As DIG in one area I had recruited a few boys from the families which traditionally brewed illegal liquor. After a while, it became a contradiction for the family to have a law enforcement officer and the criminals living under the same roof. They gradually gave up crime.
people are going to see what they want to see when you collect money for a noble cause. Undeterred you need to carry on.
Hi there- great info- what lodge do you run? I would like to come and visit- my email is jscorse@gmail.com and I am a professor of environmental policy. I started seeing the Grateful Dead at 12 back in 1981 and still miss Jerry. Hope to hear from you.
Jason Scorse, PhD
Dear Aditya,
I would compare the people who say
you made money from Indala to people
who try to spit at the sky.
They are maligning themselves.
You soldier on. Just look at the
heart filling response from the
common public for your blog.
May I ask do you have Mr. Fateh
Singh and Valmik on board too?
From the USA how do I send money
to you can you please give some
details.
Many best wishes to you and family.
Remember rahim doha....
Bade badai na karein bade na bole bol
Rahiman hirs kab kahe lakh taka
mora mol.
Thanks for reading
God Bless you and T10.
Dear Anubhav,
Mr Valmik Thapar does not realy stay in Ranthambhore any more and Mr Fateh Singh is not internet savy. I am in touch with Dharmendra Khandal who is the Field Biologist for Tiger watch, Fateh Singh's NGO.
We dont really have any project for the next 3 months. Everything comes to a stand still during monsoons. Will start working on Indala again in November or so and will get in touch with you then.
Regards,
Aditya Singh
Post a Comment
<< Home